Making sense of Greta Thunberg

Swedish activist Greta Thunberg will be in Vancouver this Friday to participate in a climate strike at the Vancouver Art Gallery. Following is a comment by A Rocha International’s director of theology Dave Bookless.

When Greta Thunberg speaks, the world listens. How is it that a 16 year old Swedish schoolgirl, unknown just over a year ago, has become one of the best-known faces and voices on the planet?

And what about her message? The controlled anger with which she calmly addressed the United Nations [September 23] was extraordinary, as she rebuked world leaders:

‘How dare you! You have stolen my dreams and my childhood with your empty words. And yet I’m one of the lucky ones. People are suffering. People are dying. Entire ecosystems are collapsing. We are in the beginning of a mass extinction, and all you can talk about is money and fairy tales of eternal economic growth. How dare you!’

Do watch her entire speech if you can (see video below):

As I watched Greta speaking, I found myself asking, ‘Is this a prophet?’ For some years I’ve been praying for a unifying figure to inspire the climate movement. The issues are so enormous and so complex. Politicians seem largely mired in short-term thinking, compromised by self-interest, or puppets of powerful economic influencers. Where is the Wilberforce, Gandhi, Mandela or Martin Luther King for people to rally around today?

Biblically, of course, there is precedent for God raising up somebody from beyond the faithful to fulfil his purpose. The pagan Persian King Cyrus is described as inspired by God (Ezra 1:1-8) and as God’s ‘shepherd’ (Isaiah 44:28).

Greta has stirred strong reactions. [Last month] an estimated four million people worldwide joined her strike for the climate. She has been credited with inspiring a doubling of the European Green vote in the 2019 EU elections, and with influencing governments to declare a ‘Climate Emergency.’ Yet, she has also been attacked, sometimes with extraordinary vitriol, accused of being simplistic, of being hypocritical and (as I found when I retweeted her comments) by some Christians, of being the figurehead of a ‘new religion’ of climate panic.

So, how do we assess Greta Thunberg from a biblical perspective? She does not publicly claim any Christian faith, and it’s fairly easy to find things to disagree with in what she says.

She speaks of never forgiving today’s generation of leaders for refusing to take the necessary drastic action, whereas we believe there is always room for repentance and forgiveness. She supports the illegal (albeit nonviolent) protests of Extinction Rebellion, which causes unease amongst many. Her language is sometimes apocalyptic, encouraging climate anxiety and even despair, and could feed a deep anger against the rich and powerful.

Yet, in her despair and rage, her outspoken passion and clarity, she sounds remarkably like Amos or Ezekiel railing against the injustice, corruption and vested interests of their day, or even like Jesus’ ‘Woe to you’s’ in Matthew 23.

Ultimately, the place where I part company most with Greta is in where she finds hope. For her, as for most involved in the global climate movement, hope is found in humanity. This is a crisis we have to solve ourselves, the narrative goes, because we caused it and we are the only ones who can sort it. Only science, education and direct action, leading to economic and political transformation will get us out of this mess, or at least reduce its worst impacts.

Yet, for Christians, the human heart cannot be changed by campaigns, collective action or new consciousness. Only God’s Spirit can re-order our disordered desires. And, whilst our short-term, proximate, hopes will be dashed time and time again, our ultimate hope is not in ourselves, but in God’s saving work in Christ, through whose death on the cross all things in heaven and on earth will be reconciled to God.

So, where does that leave us in thinking about how to react to the phenomenon of Greta Thunberg? Prophet or not, I would urge us as Christians to listen to her seriously: not just to her words, but to her pain and anger as she articulates what so many millions of young people are feeling.

Hearing her speech to the UN, I found myself lamenting anew for God’s groaning creation, repenting for my own compromised lifestyle, committing myself to seeking God’s kingdom here on earth as it is in heaven, by working for a better world alongside the young people I know.

So, please listen to Greta, and also to the young people you know – those in our churches who long to see God’s creation preached about, prayed for and cared for – and those who currently shun our churches because they sadly believe the Gospel of Jesus has nothing to offer in a time of climate crisis. How shall they hear without someone preaching . . . and demonstrating . . . the hope for people and planet that we have in Christ Jesus?

This comment originally appeared on A Rocha International’s blog and is re-posted by permission.

Rev. Dr. Dave Bookless is director of theology for A Rocha International, where he works to embed creation care into international Christian organizations, theological institutions and mission movements. His past roles with A Rocha include being an international trustee and the co-founder of A Rocha UK (with his wife Anne).

He has a PhD from Cambridge University on biblical theology and biodiversity conservation, and has contributed to many books and articles, including Planetwise, available in six languages. Born and raised in India, Dave has a love for Indian food, Indian culture and Indian Christianity. Dave is also a qualified bird-ringer and loves birding, islands, running and mountains.

3 comments for “Making sense of Greta Thunberg

  1. Alan Roxburgh
    October 24, 2019 at 8:38 am

    A helpful framing. It is about the ordering of our desires rather than simply the science of climate change. Climate and human responsibility go deeper than just oil or what we eat, etc. It goes to the core of human identity which in late modernity is too often about self-development and self-expression. The object of our desires needs to be radically transformed and this, indeed, requires something fundamentally different from science, as important as that is.

  2. Satomi Hirano
    October 24, 2019 at 6:58 pm

    I always remember what Derek Prince once said, that he erred most not because he was wrong but his truth was incomplete. I was an active advocate of climate change and still do believe in sustainable solutions but I was informed that there are other perspectives based on science and facts not being told, and we need to hear all sides. My prayer is that God will raise up a media network that informs rather than shapes opinions and not beholden to the agenda of their funders.

  3. Angela L.
    October 25, 2019 at 12:40 pm

    Thank you for sharing this perspective. And I appreciate the comments above, as well. I might have chosen a different title for the piece, though. It’s ok to “make sense” of some*thing* but demeaning to say you’re going to make sense of some*one*, especially in light of the fact she is someone with special needs. The piece itself is appreciated, though.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.