This piece is excerpted from Theology in Aisle Seven: The uncommon grace of everyday spirituality. Carolyn Arends will expand on the theme during Conversations About Worship March 1 at Pacific Life Bible College in Surrey. Joining her as speakers will be Roy Salmond, Darlene Ketchum and Lincoln Tatem.
On a recent family vacation, we stayed with two sets of friends. We spent the first night in a small prairie town, in the lovely but simple home of some fellow musicians who fed us hamburgers and offered us a hide-a-bed. The second night we spent visiting the gorgeous, new urban house of wealthier friends who fed us organic roast and outfitted the guest bed with 1,000-thread-count sheets.
In both places, the hospitality was extraordinary. Both hosts thought of what we needed before we did – clean towels, snacks for the road. Although the resources were quite different, the spirit was wonderfully the same. We felt so at home both nights that we talked into the wee hours about things that mattered, including our jobs, our families and our churches.
I’ve attended some 2,000 church services in my lifetime, both as a church member and as a guest musician at a wide variety of gatherings across North America. I’ve participated in many different approaches to ‘doing’ church.
We’ve sung from hymnals, songbooks and PowerPoint slides with slick video backgrounds. We’ve been accompanied by choirs, folk singers and rock bands. We’ve heard preaching from ministers in robes, suits and graphic tees. We’ve met in cathedrals, sanctuaries, gymnasiums and living rooms. We’ve read formal liturgies and followed the unspoken liturgies of a particular church’s service format. Almost always, we have taken an offering.
We have called it all ‘church,’ and we’ve argued about the right way to do it in order to give God glory, reach seekers and foster spiritual growth. Sometimes we’ve had trouble separating our aesthetic preferences from our theologies and the guidance of the Holy Spirit.
I have my own biases, and it’s almost impossible to perceive any worship service outside of that lens. But lately I’ve been constructing a mental catalog of gatherings I’ve attended that were especially worshipful, challenging or nourishing. I’ve been shocked by how widely they range in style, size and polish. I can recall a wonderful communal awareness of God’s presence in churches mega and miniscule, charismatic and conservative, contemporary and classical. (And I have found only empty ritual in a similar range of gatherings.)
Evidently, God will move wherever and whenever he pleases, regardless of our resources and plans. But when I look at my list of the most memorable gatherings, I see certain commonalities. Each of those services – whether led by a gifted team of professionals or by decidedly less proficient volunteers – was thoroughly christocentric and profoundly reverent. No surprises there. The common characteristic that I least expected? Hospitality.
Robert Webber was the first person I heard speak about hospitality in the context of worship. He told a story about attending an unfamiliar church while travelling. About half of the church members constituted the choir, sitting up front in the loft. When it was time to sing, the choir director turned to the congregation and took the time to teach each parishioner his part, going over the soprano, alto, tenor and bass lines until everyone knew what to do.
Webber claimed that in the course of the opening song, guided by the choir at the front, he went from being a stranger to someone who belonged. He knew exactly how to enter into that community’s worship, because he had been taught his part in it.
“In the church,” Webber concluded, “singing is hospitality.”
I’ve been in churches where the singing (not to mention the praying and preaching) is impressive and professional, but not hospitable. Those services have been more of a show than a family reunion, more a presentation than a meal together at a life-giving table. They have been effective to a point, but they haven’t held a candle to hospitable churches that use every resource available (from the church’s architecture to its care in establishing and teaching its liturgies in any style) to make each person included and sure of her part.
Hospitality matters because every time we worship together, we are drawn not only into our particular community, but also into the community of angels and saints who are always praising God. Even better, we are being reminded that we are included in the circle of fellowship between the Father, Son and Spirit. The Son is the true worship leader who helps us express our thanks to the Father, the phenomenally hospitable God who invites us to make ourselves at home with him.
Church is powerful when it embodies this inclusion – much like our hospitable friends did on our recent family vacation. When church is like that, it becomes the home away from home where we offer each other a place to reunite, be fed, commune, wash, rest and receive what we need for the road.